Part One: What Has Ceased (Articles 1 to 3)
Article 1
The Holy Spirit, the Book of Acts, and the Myth of Two-Tier Christianity
I was once a pastor in the Charismatic movement, so I am not writing as someone who has only studied these issues from the outside. I know the language. I know the expectations. I know the sincere desire many have for more of God. But I also know what it is like to be told that there is “more” available to the Christian: a second experience, a baptism of the Holy Spirit, often said to be evidenced by speaking in tongues.
I had to ask a very important question. Is this what the Bible actually teaches?
That is the question that must govern us. Not experience. Not pressure. Not tradition. Not what happened to someone we know. Not what a respected teacher told us. The question is: what does Scripture say?
How to read the book of Acts
One of the major mistakes often made in Pentecostal and Charismatic circles is treating the book of Acts as though every recorded experience in it is intended to become the normal pattern for every Christian in every age. Acts is inspired Scripture. It is the Word of God. But Acts is also a book of redemptive history. It records a unique and unrepeatable period in which the risen Christ, having accomplished redemption, pours out the promised Spirit and gathers His new covenant people.
The issue is not whether Acts is true. Of course it is. The issue is how Acts is meant to function. Is Luke giving us a normative pattern for every believer, or an inspired description of what happened during a unique transitional period in redemptive history? Pentecostal and Charismatic theology often reads Acts through prescriptive glasses. “This happened in Acts, therefore this should happen to us.” But that assumes the very thing that must be proven. Description is not the same as prescription, and inspired history is not automatically universal instruction. The glasses we put on at this point will shape what we think we are seeing on every page.
This distinction takes nothing away from a believer’s confidence in the Spirit’s work. It protects believers from being pressured into experiences Scripture never commands them to seek.
The boundary moments in Acts
In Acts, we see the gospel moving outward according to the program Jesus Himself announced, that “you will be my witnesses in Jerusalem and in all Judea and Samaria, and to the end of the earth” (Acts 1:8). That movement is the public, historical expansion of the one church of Jesus Christ.
At Pentecost in Acts 2, the Spirit is poured out upon Jews gathered in Jerusalem. In Acts 8, the Samaritans are visibly brought into the same one people of God. In Acts 10, Gentiles receive the Spirit, making it unmistakably clear that they are accepted by God through faith in Christ, without becoming Jews. In Acts 19, disciples associated with John the Baptist’s ministry are brought into the full light of new covenant fulfillment.
These are major boundary moments in the history of redemption. They show that there is one Christ, one gospel, one church, and one Spirit for all who believe.
But what about the gap in Acts 8, where the Samaritans believe and are baptized but do not receive the Spirit until Peter and John arrive from Jerusalem? Pentecostal teachers often press this passage hard, arguing that it proves a separation between conversion and Spirit reception. The better explanation is redemptive-historical. Centuries of hostility stood between Jews and Samaritans. If Samaritan believers had received the Spirit independently of the apostolic church in Jerusalem, a very real danger existed that two parallel churches would form, one Jewish and one Samaritan, divided by the old animosity rather than united in the one body of Christ. These Samaritans had already believed the gospel, and faith is itself the work of the Holy Spirit. What was delayed was the open, visible giving of the Spirit. Luke does not tell us why, but he shows us the result. It came when the Jerusalem apostles arrived, and the Samaritans were openly grafted into the same body. That is the most likely purpose of so unusual a delay. It is not a pattern for ordinary Christian experience.
Acts 19 is similar. The “disciples” Paul meets at Ephesus had only known the baptism of John. They had not heard of Pentecost or the giving of the Spirit, and it appears they had not yet heard the full Christian gospel either. They appear to be disciples connected to John’s preparatory ministry, not ordinary new covenant Christians who had received Christ but somehow lacked the Spirit. When Paul instructs them in the gospel, baptizes them in the name of the Lord Jesus, and lays hands on them, they are brought into new covenant fulfillment for the first time. Their experience parallels the disciples in Acts 1 to 2, not the experience of someone today who has already trusted Christ and is being told there is a second blessing yet to seek.
The settled doctrine in the epistles
We must let Acts be Acts, and then let the epistles give us the settled doctrinal explanation of what is true for every Christian.
Paul writes, “For in one Spirit we were all baptized into one body—Jews or Greeks, slaves or free—and all were made to drink of one Spirit” (1 Corinthians 12:13). Notice the word “all.” Paul does not divide the Corinthian church into ordinary believers and Spirit-baptized believers. He does not say some Christians have been baptized by the Spirit while others still need to seek it. He says all believers have been baptized in one Spirit into one body.
Whatever this baptism is, every believer in Corinth had received it.
The same truth is reinforced elsewhere. “Anyone who does not have the Spirit of Christ does not belong to him” (Romans 8:9). That means there is no such thing as a true Christian who belongs to Christ but does not yet have the Spirit. Paul also writes that believers were sealed with the promised Holy Spirit when they heard the word of truth and believed the gospel (Ephesians 1:13).
So the New Testament does not teach a two-stage Christian life in which a person first receives Christ, and then later receives the Spirit in some higher, fuller, second baptism. The Spirit is not an optional addition to Christ. To have Christ is to have the Spirit. To belong to Christ is to be indwelt by the Spirit.
One baptism or two?
To be fair, careful Pentecostal teachers do not say that an ordinary believer has no Spirit. The Assemblies of God teaches that the Spirit indwells every believer from the new birth. What it adds is a second event. At conversion the Spirit places the believer into the body of Christ. Later, in a separate experience, Christ baptizes that believer in the Spirit to give power for life and service.
So the question is whether Scripture knows two such baptisms. I cannot find them. John the Baptist promised that Christ would baptize with the Holy Spirit (Matthew 3:11). Paul uses the same expression in the Greek of 1 Corinthians 12:13 and says it has already happened to all who belong to Christ. The epistles never tell a Christian to seek it. They tell Christians to walk by the Spirit, to be filled with the Spirit, and not to grieve the Spirit, and they write to them as people who already have what Christ gives.
Spirit baptism and Spirit filling are not the same
We need to be careful here. The Bible does teach repeated fillings of the Spirit. The same people who were filled with the Spirit in Acts 2 are filled again in Acts 4:31. Paul commands believers to “be filled with the Spirit” (Ephesians 5:18). These are people already in Christ, already sealed with the Spirit, already members of the body of Christ. Yet they are commanded to be filled with the Spirit. The verb form Paul uses points to ongoing action, not a once-for-all event. It could be rendered, “Be continually filled with the Spirit.” This is not a command to seek a second Spirit baptism. It is a command for believers to live in ongoing dependence upon the Spirit’s power, influence, and grace.
So yes, Christians should desire the Spirit’s ongoing work. We should desire more holiness, more boldness, more love, more assurance, more fruitfulness, more conformity to Christ.
But that is not the same thing as a second Spirit baptism.
Spirit baptism is the Spirit’s work of uniting every believer to Christ and to His body. Spirit filling refers to the Spirit’s ongoing work in empowering, strengthening, sanctifying, and governing the believer’s life.
Notice also what follows in Ephesians 5. The evidence of being filled with the Spirit is not tongues, but worship, thanksgiving, humility, submission, and a life increasingly ordered under the lordship of Christ.
Tongues are not the test
This also means that tongues are not the biblical evidence that someone has received the Spirit. The New Testament never teaches that every believer must speak in tongues. Paul explicitly asks, “Do all speak with tongues?” (1 Corinthians 12:30). The grammar of Paul’s question expects the answer no.
Not every Pentecostal makes tongues the test. The Elim Pentecostal Church in Britain speaks of a baptism in the Spirit “with signs following” and does not name tongues as the necessary sign. Where tongues are taught as the evidence, as in the Assemblies of God, the answer given is that Paul is speaking there of the gift of tongues used in the gathered church, and that the tongues which mark Spirit baptism are the same in kind but serve a different purpose. That distinction has to be brought to the text, because Paul does not make it. And no passage in the epistles tells believers to look for tongues as the sign that the Spirit has come upon them.
Some will respond by appealing to Hebrews 13:8: “Jesus Christ is the same yesterday and today and forever.” Of course He is. Every Christian gladly confesses this. But the verse teaches Christ’s unchanging person, character, faithfulness, power, and saving sufficiency. It does not teach that Christ must do the same works in the same way through every servant in every era.
David never parted seas or brought plagues upon Egypt. Moses never sat on a throne in Jerusalem. Elijah called down fire from heaven, yet John the Baptist performed no sign, though Jesus said that among those born of women none was greater than John. The unchanging God does not always work in the same way through every servant or at every stage of redemptive history. To confuse God’s unchanging nature with an unchanging method is a serious interpretive mistake.
What pressing further into the Spirit actually means
The biblical alternative to seeking a second baptism is not coldness toward the Spirit. It is seeking the Spirit’s ongoing work in the way Scripture actually teaches.
The Holy Spirit is profoundly active today. He regenerates sinners, causing those who were dead in trespasses and sins to be born again (John 3:3-8; Titus 3:5). He convicts the world concerning sin, righteousness, and judgment (John 16:8). He opens blind eyes to behold the glory of Christ in the gospel (2 Corinthians 4:6). He grants faith and repentance as sinners are brought savingly to Christ (Philippians 1:29; 2 Timothy 2:25). He unites believers to Christ (1 Corinthians 12:13). He indwells every true believer (Romans 8:9). He assures God’s children that they belong to the Father (Romans 8:15-16). He sanctifies the people of God, conforming them increasingly to the image of Christ (2 Thessalonians 2:13; 1 Peter 1:2). He produces His fruit in their lives: love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, and self-control (Galatians 5:22-23). He illumines the Word, enabling believers to understand and obey what God has revealed (1 Corinthians 2:12-14). He empowers the preaching of the gospel (1 Thessalonians 1:5; 1 Corinthians 2:4-5). He strengthens weak saints, comforts the suffering, helps us in prayer, and preserves us until the day of Christ (Romans 8:26-27; Ephesians 3:16; Philippians 1:6).
That is not the work of an absent or inactive Spirit. That is the work of the Spirit who has been poured out upon every believer who is in Christ.
No Christian lacks the Spirit
There are not two classes of Christians: those who merely believe in Christ and those who have received the Spirit. All who belong to Christ have the Spirit (Romans 8:9). All who are united to Christ have been brought into the one body by the one Spirit. All are called to walk by the Spirit, be filled with the Spirit, bear the fruit of the Spirit, and worship the Son whom the Spirit delights to glorify.
If you are in Christ, you are not lacking the Holy Spirit. You may need to grow. You may need to repent. You may need to be freshly strengthened, humbled, and comforted. But you are not a second-class Christian. Christ has given you His Spirit, and the Spirit’s great work is not to draw attention to Himself through spectacle, but to glorify the Lord Jesus Christ in and through His people.
So let us seek the Spirit’s work with all our hearts. Let us pray for His power in preaching. Let us depend upon Him in evangelism. Let us ask Him to sanctify us, comfort us, humble us, strengthen us, and make Christ precious to us.
But let us not chase an unbiblical second baptism.
The fullness of the Christian life is not found in tongues, private revelations, or dramatic experiences. It is found in Christ Himself, by the Spirit, through the Word, to the glory of God.
A related but distinct question is whether the apostolic sign gifts of tongues, prophecy, and miraculous authentication continue today as ordinary gifts in the church. Many who believe they do also reject the two-stage teaching answered here, so theirs is a different case and deserves its own hearing. That question is taken up in the next two articles in this series.
About this series
“The Spirit Who Is Anything but Absent” is a six-part series on the work of the Holy Spirit today.
Part One: What Has Ceased
- The Holy Spirit, the Book of Acts, and the Myth of Two-Tier Christianity
- Are the Apostolic Sign Gifts for Today? A Biblical Case for Cessationism
- Tongues, Prophecy, and Common Objections to Cessationism
Part Two: What Has Not (three articles to follow)