Are the Apostolic Sign Gifts for Today? A Biblical Case for Cessationism

In a previous article, I argued that the New Testament does not teach a two-stage Christian life in which a believer first receives Christ and then later receives some second baptism of the Holy Spirit. Every true believer in Christ has the Spirit. There are not two classes of Christians.

That is one question. A related but distinct question is this: does the Holy Spirit still give the apostolic sign gifts (tongues, prophecy, and miraculous authentication) as ordinary gifts in the church today?

The position I hold, sometimes called cessationism, says that those particular gifts belonged to the founding era of the church. They served to authenticate the apostolic witness. With the apostolic foundation laid and the apostolic witness preserved for the church in Scripture, those gifts have ceased as the ordinary experience of the church.

By “ordinary,” I mean the normal, expected, continuing pattern for the church in every generation.

Cessationism is often caricatured. So before laying out the positive case, let me clear the ground.

What cessationism is not

Cessationism is not the belief that God no longer acts supernaturally. It is the belief that certain revelatory and confirmatory gifts served a foundational purpose and are not continuing as ordinary gifts in the church.

Cessationism does not say the Holy Spirit is inactive. Far from it. The Spirit regenerates, indwells, sanctifies, illumines, comforts, intercedes, empowers preaching, produces fruit, and preserves believers until the day of Christ. Without the Spirit there is no Christian life at all.

Cessationism does not say God cannot heal today. He can, He does, and He answers prayer. The same God who delivered Israel through the Red Sea is the God we approach today. He works providentially in countless ways, including in answer to prayer for the sick.

Cessationism does not deny that God can do unusual or remarkable things in His providence. He has all power. He is sovereign over every event.

What cessationism does say is more limited. The specific apostolic sign gifts (tongues as recognizable languages, prophecy as authoritative new revelation, miracles wrought through human agents to authenticate the apostolic witness) were given for the foundational era of the church. They are not the ordinary experience of the church in every age.

Why do I believe that? Here are the main biblical reasons.

1. Miracles in Scripture cluster around specific moments

If you read your Bible cover to cover, you might assume miracles are sprinkled evenly throughout. They are not. The miraculous activity of God through human agents tends to cluster in three concentrated periods.

The first cluster is the time of Moses and Joshua, when God formed Israel out of slavery in Egypt and brought her into the promised land. The second cluster is the time of Elijah and Elisha, when God confronted Israel’s deep descent into idolatry under Ahab and Jezebel. The third cluster is the time of Christ and His apostles, when God sent His Son into the world and inaugurated the new covenant.

Yes, there are miracles outside these clusters. Daniel saw remarkable things. In Hezekiah’s day, at Isaiah’s word, the shadow went back ten steps on the dial of Ahaz. But the dense, sustained miracle-working through specific human agents is concentrated in those three eras.

What ties these three eras together? Each one marks a major foundational moment in the history of redemption. Each one introduces something new: the giving of the law, the prophetic call to repentance against systemic apostasy, the coming of Christ Himself.

The miraculous sign gifts in the New Testament are tied to the founding moment of the new covenant church. They are not a permanent feature of every age. They cluster, as they always have, around the moments God ordained for them.

This pattern does not prove everything by itself. The heavier exegetical weight comes from the texts that follow. But it should caution us against assuming that miracle-working through human agents is evenly distributed throughout redemptive history.

2. The foundation has been laid

Paul writes that the church is “built on the foundation of the apostles and prophets, Christ Jesus himself being the cornerstone” (Ephesians 2:20).

Notice the image. Paul is describing the church as a building. Christ is the cornerstone, the apostles and prophets are the foundation, and the rest of us are the stones built upon that foundation.

A foundation is laid once. Once it is laid, the building rises on it. You do not lay a foundation again on the second floor. You do not lay it again on the roof. The foundation belongs to the building, but it has a unique, unrepeated role.

The apostles and prophets in this passage are paired together. In Paul’s Greek a single “the” covers both nouns, joining the two groups as one foundation. They are most likely new covenant prophets, the ones Paul mentions elsewhere alongside apostles (Ephesians 3:5; 4:11). Their foundation-laying ministry gave the church its once-for-all apostolic witness, now preserved for us in the New Testament Scriptures.

Once that foundation was laid, it did not need to be laid again. The church was given the apostolic witness, preserved for us in Scripture, and built upon it.

Paul does not say in this verse that the sign gifts would cease. That conclusion comes from setting this passage beside the two that follow. But the step is a short one. If the signs were given to authenticate the founding witness, they belong to the founding moment. They are foundation gifts, not roof gifts.

3. The signs of an apostle

Paul calls miraculous signs the “signs of a true apostle.” Defending his apostolic authority to the Corinthians, he writes:

“The signs of a true apostle were performed among you with utmost patience, with signs and wonders and mighty works” (2 Corinthians 12:12).

This is not a casual phrase. Paul calls these signs the “signs of a true apostle.” Not the signs of a Christian. Not the signs of a Spirit-filled believer. The signs of an apostle.

That does not mean no one else worked a sign in those years. Stephen did, and so did Philip (Acts 6:8; 8:6), and Paul speaks of the working of miracles in the church at Corinth (1 Corinthians 12:10). His point is that signs were how an apostle’s claim was confirmed. They belonged to the years when the apostles’ message was being delivered and attested, whoever’s hands God used.

The reason is plain. The apostles were laying the foundation of the church. They were delivering new covenant revelation. They were speaking with Christ’s own authority. How were people to know that their message was from God and not from man? The signs and wonders authenticated their claim.

Once the apostolic ministry was complete, the purpose of those signs was fulfilled. Their function was to mark out the apostolic witness as bearing divine authority. With the New Testament now in our hands, that function has been served.

4. How the gospel was authenticated

Hebrews makes the same point. The writer is reflecting on how the message of salvation came to the church.

“It was declared at first by the Lord, and it was attested to us by those who heard, while God also bore witness by signs and wonders and various miracles and by gifts of the Holy Spirit distributed according to his will” (Hebrews 2:3-4).

Notice the structure. The Lord declared the message. Those who heard Him passed it on. God bore witness to that message by signs, wonders, miracles, and gifts of the Spirit.

The whole passage looks back to the original delivery and confirmation of the gospel message. It describes what happened in the foundation-laying era. The signs and wonders authenticated the apostolic witness as the Lord’s witnesses passed on what they had heard.

The author of Hebrews is not promising that those signs will continue uniformly throughout church history. He is explaining how the church received its authoritative testimony in the first place: by the apostles’ testimony, confirmed by God’s signs.

That is the language of a foundation being laid and a message being confirmed. It describes how the church began, not how the church must always be.

But isn’t there only one church age?

Some will object: “But there is only one church age. We are still in it. We should not divide what God has not divided.”

Yes and no.

Yes, there is one new covenant church, one gospel, one Spirit, one body of Christ. The church that began at Pentecost is the same church that is gathered today.

But Scripture itself distinguishes between the foundation-laying ministry of the apostles and prophets and the ongoing life of the church built upon that foundation. Paul makes that distinction in Ephesians 2. The author of Hebrews makes that distinction in Hebrews 2. To recognize a difference between the founding era and the building era is not to divide the church. It is to read Scripture carefully.

A foundation belongs to the building. But a foundation is not laid again and again on every floor, and certainly not on the roof.

What this does and does not mean

Cessationism, properly understood, is freeing.

It does not mean God is silent. He has spoken in His Son, and that word stands.

It does not mean the Spirit is absent. He is more profoundly active in the lives of believers than we will ever fully understand in this life.

It does not mean prayer is futile. We pray boldly, knowing the God who hears prayer is the same God who parted the Red Sea.

It does not mean God has stopped healing. He has not promised always to heal in this life, but He has promised to raise every believer to imperishable life when Christ returns.

What it does mean is that we do not need new revelation to know God. We do not need new signs to confirm the gospel. We do not need to chase after experiences that the New Testament did not promise to every Christian.

The question is not whether God can speak. The question is whether He has given the church a sufficient, final, apostolic Word by which we are to test all claims.

The Spirit now works ordinarily through the means God has appointed. The Word preached. The ordinances rightly administered. Prayer. Fellowship. Discipline. Worship. The quiet but mighty operations of grace in the hearts of God’s people.

None of this is second best. These are the very channels through which the Spirit continues to glorify Christ and conform His people into His image.

A closing word

Cessationism is not a cold position. It is a position that takes seriously what the Bible teaches about the foundational role of the apostles and prophets, and finds rest in the sufficiency of Scripture and the means of grace God has appointed.

The Spirit’s great delight is to glorify the Son. To be filled with the Spirit is to be increasingly captivated by Christ, and the fullness of the Christian life is found in Him.

In the next article I will address the most common objections to cessationism: 1 Corinthians 13 and “when the perfect comes,” 1 Corinthians 14 and the command to desire spiritual gifts, the question of modern tongues and prophecy, Hebrews 13:8, and the difficulty of allowing prophecy that may turn out to be wrong.

Recommended resources

For the fuller positive case, I commend Tom Pennington’s book A Biblical Case for Cessationism: Why the Miraculous Gifts of the Spirit Have Ended (G3 Press, 2023). Pennington lays out seven biblical arguments for the cessation of the miraculous gifts. The book is concise (about 200 pages), accessible to lay readers, and pastorally written. It is the best recent treatment I know.

Also worth reading: Richard Gaffin’s Perspectives on Pentecost (a more academic treatment), Sinclair Ferguson’s The Holy Spirit (deeply pastoral), and the older but still excellent Counterfeit Miracles by B. B. Warfield.

About this series

“The Spirit Who Is Anything but Absent” is a six-part series on the work of the Holy Spirit today.

Part One: What Has Ceased

  1. The Holy Spirit, the Book of Acts, and the Myth of Two-Tier Christianity
  2. Are the Apostolic Sign Gifts for Today? A Biblical Case for Cessationism
  3. Tongues, Prophecy, and Common Objections to Cessationism

Part Two: What Has Not (three articles to follow)

The Spirit Who Is Anything but Absent

Part One: What Has Ceased (Articles 1 to 3)

Article 1

The Holy Spirit, the Book of Acts, and the Myth of Two-Tier Christianity

I was once a pastor in the Charismatic movement, so I am not writing as someone who has only studied these issues from the outside. I know the language. I know the expectations. I know the sincere desire many have for more of God. But I also know what it is like to be told that there is “more” available to the Christian: a second experience, a baptism of the Holy Spirit, often said to be evidenced by speaking in tongues.

I had to ask a very important question. Is this what the Bible actually teaches?

That is the question that must govern us. Not experience. Not pressure. Not tradition. Not what happened to someone we know. Not what a respected teacher told us. The question is: what does Scripture say?

How to read the book of Acts

One of the major mistakes often made in Pentecostal and Charismatic circles is treating the book of Acts as though every recorded experience in it is intended to become the normal pattern for every Christian in every age. Acts is inspired Scripture. It is the Word of God. But Acts is also a book of redemptive history. It records a unique and unrepeatable period in which the risen Christ, having accomplished redemption, pours out the promised Spirit and gathers His new covenant people.

The issue is not whether Acts is true. Of course it is. The issue is how Acts is meant to function. Is Luke giving us a normative pattern for every believer, or an inspired description of what happened during a unique transitional period in redemptive history? Pentecostal and Charismatic theology often reads Acts through prescriptive glasses. “This happened in Acts, therefore this should happen to us.” But that assumes the very thing that must be proven. Description is not the same as prescription, and inspired history is not automatically universal instruction. The glasses we put on at this point will shape what we think we are seeing on every page.

This distinction takes nothing away from a believer’s confidence in the Spirit’s work. It protects believers from being pressured into experiences Scripture never commands them to seek.

The boundary moments in Acts

In Acts, we see the gospel moving outward according to the program Jesus Himself announced, that “you will be my witnesses in Jerusalem and in all Judea and Samaria, and to the end of the earth” (Acts 1:8). That movement is the public, historical expansion of the one church of Jesus Christ.

At Pentecost in Acts 2, the Spirit is poured out upon Jews gathered in Jerusalem. In Acts 8, the Samaritans are visibly brought into the same one people of God. In Acts 10, Gentiles receive the Spirit, making it unmistakably clear that they are accepted by God through faith in Christ, without becoming Jews. In Acts 19, disciples associated with John the Baptist’s ministry are brought into the full light of new covenant fulfillment.

These are major boundary moments in the history of redemption. They show that there is one Christ, one gospel, one church, and one Spirit for all who believe.

But what about the gap in Acts 8, where the Samaritans believe and are baptized but do not receive the Spirit until Peter and John arrive from Jerusalem? Pentecostal teachers often press this passage hard, arguing that it proves a separation between conversion and Spirit reception. The better explanation is redemptive-historical. Centuries of hostility stood between Jews and Samaritans. If Samaritan believers had received the Spirit independently of the apostolic church in Jerusalem, a very real danger existed that two parallel churches would form, one Jewish and one Samaritan, divided by the old animosity rather than united in the one body of Christ. These Samaritans had already believed the gospel, and faith is itself the work of the Holy Spirit. What was delayed was the open, visible giving of the Spirit. Luke does not tell us why, but he shows us the result. It came when the Jerusalem apostles arrived, and the Samaritans were openly grafted into the same body. That is the most likely purpose of so unusual a delay. It is not a pattern for ordinary Christian experience.

Acts 19 is similar. The “disciples” Paul meets at Ephesus had only known the baptism of John. They had not heard of Pentecost or the giving of the Spirit, and it appears they had not yet heard the full Christian gospel either. They appear to be disciples connected to John’s preparatory ministry, not ordinary new covenant Christians who had received Christ but somehow lacked the Spirit. When Paul instructs them in the gospel, baptizes them in the name of the Lord Jesus, and lays hands on them, they are brought into new covenant fulfillment for the first time. Their experience parallels the disciples in Acts 1 to 2, not the experience of someone today who has already trusted Christ and is being told there is a second blessing yet to seek.

The settled doctrine in the epistles

We must let Acts be Acts, and then let the epistles give us the settled doctrinal explanation of what is true for every Christian.

Paul writes, “For in one Spirit we were all baptized into one body—Jews or Greeks, slaves or free—and all were made to drink of one Spirit” (1 Corinthians 12:13). Notice the word “all.” Paul does not divide the Corinthian church into ordinary believers and Spirit-baptized believers. He does not say some Christians have been baptized by the Spirit while others still need to seek it. He says all believers have been baptized in one Spirit into one body.

Whatever this baptism is, every believer in Corinth had received it.

The same truth is reinforced elsewhere. “Anyone who does not have the Spirit of Christ does not belong to him” (Romans 8:9). That means there is no such thing as a true Christian who belongs to Christ but does not yet have the Spirit. Paul also writes that believers were sealed with the promised Holy Spirit when they heard the word of truth and believed the gospel (Ephesians 1:13).

So the New Testament does not teach a two-stage Christian life in which a person first receives Christ, and then later receives the Spirit in some higher, fuller, second baptism. The Spirit is not an optional addition to Christ. To have Christ is to have the Spirit. To belong to Christ is to be indwelt by the Spirit.

One baptism or two?

To be fair, careful Pentecostal teachers do not say that an ordinary believer has no Spirit. The Assemblies of God teaches that the Spirit indwells every believer from the new birth. What it adds is a second event. At conversion the Spirit places the believer into the body of Christ. Later, in a separate experience, Christ baptizes that believer in the Spirit to give power for life and service.

So the question is whether Scripture knows two such baptisms. I cannot find them. John the Baptist promised that Christ would baptize with the Holy Spirit (Matthew 3:11). Paul uses the same expression in the Greek of 1 Corinthians 12:13 and says it has already happened to all who belong to Christ. The epistles never tell a Christian to seek it. They tell Christians to walk by the Spirit, to be filled with the Spirit, and not to grieve the Spirit, and they write to them as people who already have what Christ gives.

Spirit baptism and Spirit filling are not the same

We need to be careful here. The Bible does teach repeated fillings of the Spirit. The same people who were filled with the Spirit in Acts 2 are filled again in Acts 4:31. Paul commands believers to “be filled with the Spirit” (Ephesians 5:18). These are people already in Christ, already sealed with the Spirit, already members of the body of Christ. Yet they are commanded to be filled with the Spirit. The verb form Paul uses points to ongoing action, not a once-for-all event. It could be rendered, “Be continually filled with the Spirit.” This is not a command to seek a second Spirit baptism. It is a command for believers to live in ongoing dependence upon the Spirit’s power, influence, and grace.

So yes, Christians should desire the Spirit’s ongoing work. We should desire more holiness, more boldness, more love, more assurance, more fruitfulness, more conformity to Christ.

But that is not the same thing as a second Spirit baptism.

Spirit baptism is the Spirit’s work of uniting every believer to Christ and to His body. Spirit filling refers to the Spirit’s ongoing work in empowering, strengthening, sanctifying, and governing the believer’s life.

Notice also what follows in Ephesians 5. The evidence of being filled with the Spirit is not tongues, but worship, thanksgiving, humility, submission, and a life increasingly ordered under the lordship of Christ.

Tongues are not the test

This also means that tongues are not the biblical evidence that someone has received the Spirit. The New Testament never teaches that every believer must speak in tongues. Paul explicitly asks, “Do all speak with tongues?” (1 Corinthians 12:30). The grammar of Paul’s question expects the answer no.

Not every Pentecostal makes tongues the test. The Elim Pentecostal Church in Britain speaks of a baptism in the Spirit “with signs following” and does not name tongues as the necessary sign. Where tongues are taught as the evidence, as in the Assemblies of God, the answer given is that Paul is speaking there of the gift of tongues used in the gathered church, and that the tongues which mark Spirit baptism are the same in kind but serve a different purpose. That distinction has to be brought to the text, because Paul does not make it. And no passage in the epistles tells believers to look for tongues as the sign that the Spirit has come upon them.

Some will respond by appealing to Hebrews 13:8: “Jesus Christ is the same yesterday and today and forever.” Of course He is. Every Christian gladly confesses this. But the verse teaches Christ’s unchanging person, character, faithfulness, power, and saving sufficiency. It does not teach that Christ must do the same works in the same way through every servant in every era.

David never parted seas or brought plagues upon Egypt. Moses never sat on a throne in Jerusalem. Elijah called down fire from heaven, yet John the Baptist performed no sign, though Jesus said that among those born of women none was greater than John. The unchanging God does not always work in the same way through every servant or at every stage of redemptive history. To confuse God’s unchanging nature with an unchanging method is a serious interpretive mistake.

What pressing further into the Spirit actually means

The biblical alternative to seeking a second baptism is not coldness toward the Spirit. It is seeking the Spirit’s ongoing work in the way Scripture actually teaches.

The Holy Spirit is profoundly active today. He regenerates sinners, causing those who were dead in trespasses and sins to be born again (John 3:3-8; Titus 3:5). He convicts the world concerning sin, righteousness, and judgment (John 16:8). He opens blind eyes to behold the glory of Christ in the gospel (2 Corinthians 4:6). He grants faith and repentance as sinners are brought savingly to Christ (Philippians 1:29; 2 Timothy 2:25). He unites believers to Christ (1 Corinthians 12:13). He indwells every true believer (Romans 8:9). He assures God’s children that they belong to the Father (Romans 8:15-16). He sanctifies the people of God, conforming them increasingly to the image of Christ (2 Thessalonians 2:13; 1 Peter 1:2). He produces His fruit in their lives: love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, and self-control (Galatians 5:22-23). He illumines the Word, enabling believers to understand and obey what God has revealed (1 Corinthians 2:12-14). He empowers the preaching of the gospel (1 Thessalonians 1:5; 1 Corinthians 2:4-5). He strengthens weak saints, comforts the suffering, helps us in prayer, and preserves us until the day of Christ (Romans 8:26-27; Ephesians 3:16; Philippians 1:6).

That is not the work of an absent or inactive Spirit. That is the work of the Spirit who has been poured out upon every believer who is in Christ.

No Christian lacks the Spirit

There are not two classes of Christians: those who merely believe in Christ and those who have received the Spirit. All who belong to Christ have the Spirit (Romans 8:9). All who are united to Christ have been brought into the one body by the one Spirit. All are called to walk by the Spirit, be filled with the Spirit, bear the fruit of the Spirit, and worship the Son whom the Spirit delights to glorify.

If you are in Christ, you are not lacking the Holy Spirit. You may need to grow. You may need to repent. You may need to be freshly strengthened, humbled, and comforted. But you are not a second-class Christian. Christ has given you His Spirit, and the Spirit’s great work is not to draw attention to Himself through spectacle, but to glorify the Lord Jesus Christ in and through His people.

So let us seek the Spirit’s work with all our hearts. Let us pray for His power in preaching. Let us depend upon Him in evangelism. Let us ask Him to sanctify us, comfort us, humble us, strengthen us, and make Christ precious to us.

But let us not chase an unbiblical second baptism.

The fullness of the Christian life is not found in tongues, private revelations, or dramatic experiences. It is found in Christ Himself, by the Spirit, through the Word, to the glory of God.

A related but distinct question is whether the apostolic sign gifts of tongues, prophecy, and miraculous authentication continue today as ordinary gifts in the church. Many who believe they do also reject the two-stage teaching answered here, so theirs is a different case and deserves its own hearing. That question is taken up in the next two articles in this series.

About this series

“The Spirit Who Is Anything but Absent” is a six-part series on the work of the Holy Spirit today.

Part One: What Has Ceased

  1. The Holy Spirit, the Book of Acts, and the Myth of Two-Tier Christianity
  2. Are the Apostolic Sign Gifts for Today? A Biblical Case for Cessationism
  3. Tongues, Prophecy, and Common Objections to Cessationism

Part Two: What Has Not (three articles to follow)

What About the Law of Moses?

Should Christians Keep the Seventh-Day Sabbath, the Feasts, and the Food Laws?

Should a Christian keep the seventh-day Sabbath, observe the feasts of Leviticus 23, and stay away from pork? Many sincere believers say yes, and they say it with an open Bible.

The teaching goes by several names, most often Hebrew Roots or Torah observance (Torah is the Hebrew word for instruction, and it commonly refers to the law given through Moses). Its case should be heard in its strongest form, and it runs something like this. God does not change, and He does not lie. He called the Sabbath a sign forever. He called the feasts His own appointed times. He warned Israel never to add to His commands or take away from them. The prophets called Israel back to His law again and again. Jesus Himself said He did not come to abolish the Law or the Prophets. Where, then, did Moses or the Prophets ever say that the Messiah would come and change what God commanded? And if they never said it, how can the followers of Israel’s Messiah treat the Sabbath, the feasts, and the food laws as finished?

That is a serious question, asked by people who love the Lord and want to obey Him. It deserves a careful answer from Scripture.

What We Gladly Affirm

Let me begin with what every Christian should affirm, because there is more common ground here than is often supposed.

  1. Grace did not begin in Matthew. The God who gave the law at Sinai is the same God who proclaimed His own name to Moses as “merciful and gracious” (Exodus 34:6). The Bible does not have a harsh God in the Old Testament and a kind one in the New.
  2. Loving obedience to what God has commanded is never legalism. Moses joined love for God and obedience to God in a single breath (Deuteronomy 10:12–13), and Jesus did the same (John 14:15).
  3. Christians are not free from God’s moral law. Paul insists that the gospel of faith does not overthrow the law: “By no means! On the contrary, we uphold the law” (Romans 3:31). He describes himself as “not being outside the law of God but under the law of Christ” (1 Corinthians 9:21). And he names the commandments against adultery, murder, theft, and coveting as summed up in love for our neighbor (Romans 13:8–10).
  4. Gentile believers have been grafted into Israel’s olive tree, and Paul forbids us to boast over the natural branches (Romans 11:17–18).

Where Christians have spoken as though the Old Testament were an embarrassment, or as though Jesus came to rescue us from God’s law instead of from our sin, they have been wrong, and the correction is deserved.

So the disagreement is narrower than it first appears. Both sides believe God’s people must obey God. What divides us is what God now commands, and who has the right to tell us.

A Covenant “Not Like” the Old

Begin where the Old Testament itself points forward. In Jeremiah 31 God promises a new covenant. It is made “with the house of Israel and the house of Judah” (verse 31). In it God will write His law on His people’s hearts (verse 33). Those who teach Torah observance love this passage, and they are right to. But one verse in it is easy to pass over. God says the new covenant will be

“not like the covenant that I made with their fathers on the day when I took them by the hand to bring them out of the land of Egypt” (Jeremiah 31:32).

Which covenant did God make with Israel when He brought them out of Egypt? The covenant at Sinai. So here is one of Israel’s own prophets, about six hundred years before Christ, announcing in God’s name that a covenant is coming which will be different from Sinai. Did the prophets ever foretell a change? Here it is, in the very promise of the new covenant.

The book of Hebrews quotes Jeremiah’s promise in full and then tells us what it means: “In speaking of a new covenant, he makes the first one obsolete” (Hebrews 8:13).

Paul says the same in his own words. The law was added until the promised offspring should come (Galatians 3:19). It was our guardian until Christ came, and now that faith has come, we are no longer under a guardian (Galatians 3:24–25).

This matters for the Sabbath in particular. Exodus 31:16–17 calls the seventh-day Sabbath a sign between God and the children of Israel. It was the sign of the covenant made at Sinai. It is sometimes said that Christians claim Israel’s covenant while dismissing its sign. But we do not claim the Sinai covenant. We belong to the new covenant, the one God Himself said would be “not like” the old.

What, then, is the law God writes on the heart? Ezekiel describes the same promise: God will put His Spirit within His people and cause them to walk in His ways (Ezekiel 36:26–27). So the new covenant produces real obedience, from the inside out. But obedience to what? Hebrews quotes the heart promise a second time and immediately concludes that “there is no longer any offering for sin” (Hebrews 10:16–18). The sacrifices were commanded in the law of Moses. If they have ended, then the law written on the heart cannot be every statute of Sinai carried over unchanged. The Spirit gives God’s people hearts that love Him and want to do His moral will, and Paul says plainly that “love is the fulfilling of the law” (Romans 13:10).

When “Forever” Has a Horizon

But did God not call these things everlasting? He did. Exodus 31 calls the Sabbath a lasting covenant and a sign forever, and the Hebrew word is olam. If God said forever, who are we to say otherwise?

The answer is to look at how Scripture itself uses the word. It is used of the old priesthood and its sacrifices:

  1. Aaron’s priesthood is “a perpetual priesthood throughout their generations” (Exodus 40:15).
  2. The Day of Atonement, with its sacrifices, is “a statute forever” (Leviticus 16:34).

Yet every believer who confesses Jesus as our great High Priest agrees that Aaron’s priesthood has given way to a better one. Psalm 110:4 promised a priest of a different order, and Hebrews draws the conclusion: “For when there is a change in the priesthood, there is necessarily a change in the law as well” (Hebrews 7:12).

The same word even appears in Exodus 21:6, where a servant who chooses to stay with his master “shall be his slave forever.” No one believes he serves beyond the grave. He serves for life. The word can mean truly endless, and often it does. But it can also mean lasting to the far horizon of the thing being described, and the context tells us which.

So something God called “forever” at Sinai has already reached its appointed end in Christ, and all who trust Him agree on it. The only question left is what else has, and who tells us. Neither church tradition nor personal preference can settle that. Only the Word of God can. And when God brings one of His own arrangements to the goal He appointed for it, He has not broken His word. He has kept it.

Before Sinai

Two things are often pointed out from the book of Genesis, long before Israel stood at Sinai.

The first is that God rested on the seventh day, and blessed it, and made it holy (Genesis 2:2–3). That is gloriously true. Christians have differed over whether those verses set a pattern of one day in seven for all mankind. But Genesis records no command to Adam, to Noah, or to Abraham to keep the seventh day. The first time Scripture records such a command, it is given to Israel in the wilderness, after their rescue from Egypt, when the manna fell for six days and not on the seventh (Exodus 16:23–30). Nehemiah later counts the Sabbath among the things God made known to Israel through Moses (Nehemiah 9:13–14). And our Reformed brothers and sisters who do see a pattern laid down at creation agree that the seventh-day observance given to Israel has ended with the coming of Christ.

The second is that Noah knew the difference between clean and unclean animals (Genesis 7:2). He did. But the distinction there is connected with sacrifice. When Noah left the ark, he offered some of every clean animal on the altar (Genesis 8:20). When God then spoke to him about food, He gave him every moving thing that lives, as freely as the green plants (Genesis 9:3). The food laws of Leviticus 11 came later, and they were given to Israel.

The Prophets Saw It Coming

Did the prophets give any hint that the arrangements of Sinai would one day change? They gave more than a hint.

Isaiah 56 is often quoted in this discussion because it speaks of foreigners who join themselves to the LORD and keep His Sabbath. But read the verses around it. God promises eunuchs a place and a name “in my house and within my walls” (Isaiah 56:5). Under the law of Moses, such a man was barred from the assembly of the LORD (Deuteronomy 23:1). Isaiah is foretelling a day when a line drawn in the law would be redrawn by God Himself.

The same passage says the foreigners’ “burnt offerings and their sacrifices will be accepted on my altar” (Isaiah 56:7). Isaiah speaks of Sabbath-keeping and animal sacrifice side by side. We cannot carry the one forward as a literal requirement for Christians, and treat the other as fulfilled in Christ, without explaining why we read them differently. The prophets described the coming age in the language of their own, and the New Testament must show us what the fulfillment looks like.

The same is true of Isaiah 66:23, where all flesh comes to worship before the LORD from new moon to new moon and from Sabbath to Sabbath in the new heavens and the new earth. Two verses earlier, God says He will take some of them for priests and for Levites (verse 21). New moons, Sabbaths, priests, and Levites: this is the worship of the age to come, described in the vocabulary of the old.

Jeremiah foretold a day when the ark of the covenant, the very center of Israel’s worship, would be gone and no one would mind: “It shall not come to mind or be remembered or missed; it shall not be made again” (Jeremiah 3:16).

Malachi foretold a pure offering presented to God “in every place” among the nations (Malachi 1:11), although Moses permitted sacrifice only at the one place God chose (Deuteronomy 12:13–14).

And Moses himself pointed beyond Moses. In Deuteronomy 13 Israel is told to reject any prophet who leads them after other gods. That test still stands, and Jesus led no one after other gods. But five chapters later Moses gave a second instruction. God would raise up a Prophet like Moses, and “it is to him you shall listen” (Deuteronomy 18:15). God adds that He will hold to account anyone who refuses (verse 19). A faithful Israelite honors Moses by doing what Moses said, which is to listen to the One who was coming.

What Did Jesus Say?

The text most often raised is Matthew 5:17: “Do not think that I have come to abolish the Law or the Prophets; I have not come to abolish them but to fulfill them.” Amen. Jesus did not come to throw away the Law or the Prophets, and no Christian should speak as though He did.

But what does “fulfill” mean? Notice that Jesus speaks of the Law and the Prophets together, as one thing waiting to be fulfilled. Later He says that all the Prophets and the Law “prophesied until John” (Matthew 11:13). The whole Old Testament, its laws included, was pointing forward. A prophecy is not abolished when it comes true. It is kept.

Jesus adds that until heaven and earth pass away, not an iota or a dot will pass from the Law “until all is accomplished” (Matthew 5:18). Does that mean every statute of Sinai stays in force, just as it was given, until the end of the world? It cannot, because the same Scriptures tell us that the priesthood has changed (Hebrews 7:12) and that the first covenant is obsolete (Hebrews 8:13). Jesus is saying something larger. The Law will stand as the Word of God for as long as the world stands, and not one thing it pointed to will fail to arrive. Much of it has arrived already, in Him.

Verse 19 warns against relaxing even the least of these commandments, and that warning stands. No Christian is asking for leave to set aside what God commands. But which commands does God lay on His new covenant people, and in what form? That is the question the apostles answer.

Paul can even say that Christ made peace between Jew and Gentile “by abolishing the law of commandments expressed in ordinances” (Ephesians 2:15). He is not contradicting his Lord. Jesus is speaking of the Scriptures, which He upholds to the last stroke of the pen. Paul is speaking of the ordinances that kept Jew and Gentile apart, which Christ brought to their end by fulfilling them.

Did Jesus ever say anything about food? He did. In Mark 7 the argument began over eating with unwashed hands, but Jesus took it further. Nothing going into a person from outside can defile him, He said, because it enters the stomach and not the heart. What defiles a person comes from within. Mark 7:19 then reads, in the ESV, “(Thus he declared all foods clean.)” Some dispute how that phrase should be translated. But the apostles leave no doubt about where Jesus’ teaching leads, as we are about to see.

Jesus also called Himself Lord of the Sabbath (Matthew 12:8). And on the night before He died, He told the apostles that He had more to teach than they could yet bear, and that the Spirit would guide them into all the truth (John 16:12–13). It is sometimes suggested that the words of Jesus in the Gospels should count for more than the letters of Paul or the book of Hebrews. But all of Scripture is the Word of the same Lord, and the letters of Paul and the book of Hebrews are His Word as surely as the Sermon on the Mount. So what do they say?

The Question Has Been Asked Before

Nothing about this debate is new. In Acts 15, some believers who belonged to the party of the Pharisees stood up and said of the Gentile converts, “It is necessary to circumcise them and to order them to keep the law of Moses” (Acts 15:5). The apostles and elders met to decide the matter.

After much debate, Peter stood up. He asked why anyone would test God “by placing a yoke on the neck of the disciples that neither our fathers nor we have been able to bear” (Acts 15:10). Jews and Gentiles alike, he said, are saved through the grace of the Lord Jesus (verse 11).

The council then wrote to the Gentile churches: “For it has seemed good to the Holy Spirit and to us to lay on you no greater burden than these requirements” (Acts 15:28). Four items follow: to abstain from what has been sacrificed to idols, from blood, from what has been strangled, and from sexual immorality (verse 29). Three of these concern food, and Christians have understood their purpose in more than one way. But notice what the list leaves out. The seventh-day Sabbath is not there. Neither are the feasts, or the list of clean and unclean animals. The council did not ask Gentile believers to take up the law of Moses as a way of life, which is exactly what had been demanded.

Some reply that verse 21 implies the Gentiles would pick up the rest of Moses in the synagogue over time. But years later, in Acts 21:25, the Jerusalem elders repeat the same ruling to Paul, and nothing has been added to it.

Paul’s letters speak the same way.

“Therefore let no one pass judgment on you in questions of food and drink, or with regard to a festival or a new moon or a Sabbath. These are a shadow of the things to come, but the substance belongs to Christ” (Colossians 2:16–17).

Look at the list: food, festivals, new moons, Sabbaths. These are the very practices in question, and Paul calls every one of them a shadow. When the one who casts the shadow walks into the room, you are no longer enamored with the shadow.

To the Romans he writes, “One person esteems one day as better than another, while another esteems all days alike. Each one should be fully convinced in his own mind” (Romans 14:5). And of food: “I know and am persuaded in the Lord Jesus that nothing is unclean in itself” (Romans 14:14). Hebrews says that regulations about “food and drink and various washings” were “imposed until the time of reformation” (Hebrews 9:10).

Where did God authorize the change? These are the places.

The Test Case of Circumcision

One command brings the whole question into focus, and it is circumcision.

God called circumcision “an everlasting covenant” in the flesh (Genesis 17:13). The uncircumcised male was to be cut off from his people (verse 14). And no uncircumcised man could eat the Passover (Exodus 12:48). So a Gentile household that is required to keep the Passover as Moses commanded it must first have all its males circumcised. And circumcision is older than Sinai. It was given to Abraham.

Here is a question worth asking. Must a Gentile who trusts in Christ be circumcised?

If the answer is yes, Paul could not be more direct. He is not condemning the act itself, for he once had Timothy circumcised for the sake of the work among the Jews (Acts 16:3). His warning is for those who accept circumcision as necessary for their standing before God. To them he says that Christ will be of no benefit, and that such a man “is obligated to keep the whole law” (Galatians 5:2–4). And when others pressed circumcision simply as a duty for Gentile believers, the apostles at Jerusalem refused to require it (Acts 15:19, 28).

If the answer is no, then we have already agreed that a command God called everlasting, with a penalty attached, does not bind Gentile believers. The only ground for believing that is the teaching of the apostles. And the same apostles must be heard when they speak about Sabbaths, feasts, and food.

Paul’s own summary is remarkable: “For neither circumcision counts for anything nor uncircumcision, but keeping the commandments of God” (1 Corinthians 7:19). Circumcision was a commandment of God. Paul, raised a Pharisee, could write that sentence only if he saw a difference between the covenant signs given to Israel for a time and the abiding moral will of God. Christians did not invent that distinction. We received it from the apostle.

What Makes Israel Jealous?

Paul says that salvation has come to the Gentiles to make Israel jealous (Romans 11:11). Some conclude that Gentile believers should therefore take up the Torah, so that Jewish people will recognize their own way of life and be drawn to the Messiah.

But think about what jealousy requires. Israel already had the Sabbath, the feasts, and the food laws. Who grows jealous watching strangers copy what he already owns? And Paul does not say that Gentiles provoke Israel by taking up Israel’s customs. He says that salvation has come to the Gentiles. What did Israel lack? Paul tells us two chapters earlier. Gentiles who were not even pursuing righteousness obtained it by faith, while Israel, pursuing it through the law, did not arrive (Romans 9:30–32). Paul takes the word “jealous” from Moses, who foretold that God would provoke Israel by a people who were no people at all (Romans 10:19, quoting Deuteronomy 32:21).

Picture it. Gentiles who never kept a Sabbath in their lives are forgiven, filled with the Spirit, and calling the God of Abraham “Father” through Israel’s own Messiah. That is what provokes jealousy.

A Word About Liberty

None of this means a Christian may not rest on Saturday, or decline pork, or mark the Passover as a way of remembering Christ our Passover (1 Corinthians 5:7). Romans 14 protects that freedom, and the rest of us must not look down on a brother or sister who uses it. In Acts 21:20 there were thousands of Jewish believers still zealous for the law, and the apostles did not rebuke them.

The line is crossed when these practices are laid on the consciences of other believers, and when their absence is called disobedience. At that point Paul’s word is “let no one pass judgment on you,” and his counsel is firm: “For freedom Christ has set us free; stand firm therefore, and do not submit again to a yoke of slavery” (Galatians 5:1).

One more thing should be said about the seventh-day Sabbath given to Israel. It was a day of rest, and the rest it pictured has come to us in a Person. “Take my yoke upon you, and learn from me,” Jesus said, “for I am gentle and lowly in heart, and you will find rest for your souls” (Matthew 11:29). Hebrews tells us that a Sabbath rest remains for the people of God (Hebrews 4:9). We enter it now by faith, resting from our own works in the finished work of Christ, and we are urged to press on until we enter it in full (Hebrews 4:11).

As for the Lord’s Day, Acts 20:7 records believers gathered on the first day of the week to break bread. It is the day our Lord rose from the dead, and we find Christians meeting on it already in the days of the apostles.

Listen to Him

Should Christians go back to Moses in order to understand Jesus? In one sense, yes. We should read Moses, love Moses, and preach Moses. Jesus said that Moses “wrote of me” (John 5:46), and on the road to Emmaus He began with Moses and all the Prophets and explained what they said about Himself (Luke 24:27).

But Moses was never the destination. Three disciples learned that on a mountain. Jesus was transfigured before them, and Moses and Elijah appeared, talking with Him. Peter, overwhelmed, offered to build three tents, one for each. Then a bright cloud covered them and the Father spoke: “This is my beloved Son, with whom I am well pleased; listen to him” (Matthew 17:5). The disciples fell on their faces. And when they lifted up their eyes, “they saw no one but Jesus only” (Matthew 17:8).

Moses had said, “it is to him you shall listen.” On the mountain the Father said the same.

If you have been drawn toward Torah observance because you love God and want to obey Him, I honor that desire. May I ask you one thing? When you look at Israel’s Sabbath, feasts, and food laws, do you see the shadow or the One who cast it? Every lamb, every feast, every day of rest was a promise, and God has kept His promise in His Son. The law has arrived where it was always going.

Come to Him, then, and rest. To Him be glory forever. Amen.